Step aside, pumpkin spice! This year, hot apple cider is taking center stage. As autumn approaches, people are reaching for steaming cups of this delightful drink, and grocery stores are rushing to keep up with the demand. But with so many options on the shelves, how do you know which one to pick for your home?

What’s Driving the Hot Cider Comeback?

Hot apple cider has always been a beloved beverage during the fall season, but in 2025, it’s experiencing a notable resurgence in popularity. As seasonal drinks begin appearing earlier each year, many are finding comfort in warm, spiced beverages at home. For instance, ALDI’s Nature’s Nectar Spiced Apple Cider—rich with notes of cinnamon, cloves, lemon peel, and orange peel—is flying off the shelves. Priced at about $2.89 for a 64-ounce bottle, it’s not just affordable; it’s aromatic and delicious, whether served warm or chilled.

The charm of cider is rooted in nostalgia, evoking memories of visits to apple orchards, crunching leaves underfoot, and kitchens filled with the aroma of cinnamon sugar. In a year when comfort foods are trending, cider offers a warm and flavorful touch, steeped in tradition.

Editors’ Pick: The Best Store-Bought Hot Cider

In a recent blind taste test conducted by editors at Southern Living, Trader Joe’s Spiced Cider was crowned the clear winner. Tasters praised it as “spiced but balanced, sweet but tart,” with a depth of flavor that suits both solo enjoyment and as a base for a cozy hot toddy. Plus, it’s shelf-stable until opened, making it a great option for spontaneous gatherings or a cozy night in.

Other Noteworthy Options

For those lucky enough to find it, Pepin Heights Apple Cider from Ferguson’s Orchards stands out as a small-batch favorite. It excelled in as a top-ranked cider for its fresh, orchard-flavor, bright acidity, and smooth mouthfeel that lingers pleasantly.

If you prefer something more accessible, Musselman’s Apple Cider delivers a creamy, rich apple taste that feels decadent without the hefty price tag. Crafted from fresh-pressed juice, this cider receives accolades from enthusiasts for being as comforting as a homemade version.

Final Sips

For a cider that’s both balanced and versatile—perfect with baked goods or hearty stews—put Trader Joe’s Spiced Cider at the top of your list. For those in search of deeper, artisanal flavors, Pepin Heights is a must-try. And for an everyday treat with a smooth texture, Musselman’s is a reliable choice without stretching your budget.

Ultimately, serving hot cider is more than just pouring a drink; it’s about creating an ambiance. A warm mug of spiced apple cider can transform an ordinary evening into a memorable experience. So, heat it up, wrap your hands around the cup, and enjoy the rich flavors of the season.